Written by Andrea Melina Fonseca Tovar
Edited by Eleanor Casement
Coral reefs have long been recognized for their colorful fish, which inspire photographs, paintings, sculptures, and clothing, among other things. These fish are a vast diversity of shades: electric blues, vivid yellows, defined stripes, rounded bodies, and patterns that can look hand-painted. Amid this great diversity are also fish that often go unnoticed because of their duller tones, elongated bodies, and low color contrast.
But have you ever wondered how this “difference in beauty” can influence our perception of the reef and our commitment to its conservation?
A study published in PLOS Biology by Langlois et al. (2022) analyzed the aesthetic value of 2,417 reef fish species and found something disturbing: the fish we tend to consider most attractive are not necessarily among those that need our protection the most. In fact, largely the opposite is true.
What Makes a Fish Look “Pretty” to Us?
To answer this question, researchers started with something quite simple: showing people paired photos of fish and asking which one they found more beautiful.
In total, around 13,000 people participated, and each compared 30 pairs of fish. These choices were used to build an aesthetic value score. Next, researchers trained a machine learning model to recognize those preference patterns and predict the aesthetic value of thousands of additional images of fish.
The result was surprisingly consistent: fish that received the highest aesthetic scores tended to share certain visual characteristics, such as more varied and saturated colors, well-defined and repeating patterns, sharp contrast in color brightness, and relatively rounded bodies. In contrast, duller, elongated fish with less defined patterns tended to receive lower scores.
In other words, our brain seems to have certain “favorites” when looking at a reef, and, when it comes to conservation, that matters more than it seems.
Beauty Has a Bias Too
Aesthetics are one of the most direct ways people connect emotionally with nature. A creature that surprises us, thrills us, or we perceive as beautiful can spark curiosity, empathy, and a desire to protect it.
The problem arises when that connection tends to concentrate on the same types of animals. In reef fish, species with higher aesthetic value often fall into similar lineages and ecological niches. Meanwhile, less attractive fish are, on average, more distinct ecologically and evolutionarily. This means they aren’t simply a “less colorful version” of the fish we like—many of these fish represent unique combinations of characteristics, functions, and ways of life.
The Unnoticed Ones May Be Most at Risk
When researchers compared aesthetics with conservation status, they found a clear difference: species classified as Threatened (including Vulnerable, Endangered, or Critically Endangered) had, on average, lower aesthetic values than species considered of Least Concern.
This doesn’t mean all threatened fish are “ugly,” nor that being pretty saves a species. There is enormous variation among species, yet this study still revealed a clear global pattern. This is especially concerning because less attractive fish also tend to be the most ecologically distinct and, therefore, likely play important functional roles on reefs. The authors also pointed out that these species have high commercial importance and therefore may be more exposed to overfishing.
How Aesthetics Ties to Conservation
When we dive, take underwater photos, or see a reef on social media, our attention is easily drawn toward the fish that stand out, which creates a connection between people and these conspicuous animals. However, that connection doesn’t mean they are the most important species in the area.
It is important to recognize that every species occupies a space, uses specific resources, interacts with others, and performs key functions within the ecosystem. Some of these species are abundant and relatively common; others are rare, evolutionarily unique, or fulfill roles that cannot be easily replaced. Losing an inconspicuous species could mean losing a lot of diversity and ecosystem function.
Researchers call this phenomenon a potential “aesthetic debt”: when our biases about which species are attractive influence—directly or indirectly—which organisms benefit from attention, research, or conservation efforts.
The authors remind us that evidence of aesthetic bias already exists in other fields of biodiversity: more charismatic species, like birds and mammals, often receive more public attention or are better represented in databases and studies.
Are We Protecting Biodiversity or Our Favorite Version of It?
Perhaps we need to learn to look at the natural world differently. The visual appeal of reefs can be one of the most powerful gateways to sparking interest in the ocean. The challenge lies in using that doorway to go further. A spectacular fish can inspire us to learn more about reefs, but in exploring further we should gain a greater appreciation for the one camouflaged among the rocks, the dull-colored one, the one that seldom appears in a photograph, and the one we might not even recognize if it swam right past us. Biodiversity isn’t defined solely by what our eyes find beautiful.
Perhaps one of the most important ways to conserve reefs is learning to find the hidden beauty in every organism.
Read the full article here: Langlois, J., Guilhaumon, F., Baletaud, F., Casajus, N., De Almeida Braga, C., Fleuré, V., Kulbicki, M., Loiseau, N., Mouillot, D., Renoult, J. P., Stahl, A., Stuart Smith, R. D., Tribot, A.-S., & Mouquet, N. (2022). The aesthetic value of reef fishes is globally mismatched to their conservation priorities. PLOS Biology, 20(6), e3001640. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3001640
